| August 23, 1822 Rev. John Seward & Rev. Wm. Hanford | |
| 1827 – 1828 Luman Lane, Philo M. Mills & Robert Hurd | |
| 1828 – 1835 Rev. Samuel Bissell | |
| 1835 – 1843 Rev. Samuel Hair, Rev. Joseph Treat, Rev. Ebenezer Ward, Rev. | |
| Chester Chapin filled in during the period when the church divided. | |
| 1843 – 1846 Rev. Robert C. Leonard | |
| 1848 – 1852 Rev. Horace W. Palmer | |
| 1853 – 1858 Rev. Joseph H. Scott | |
| 1858 – 1860 Pres. George Pierce and Prof. Henry B. Hosford | |
| 1860 – 1867 Rev. Sidney Bryant | |
| 1868 – 1868 Rev. Edward William Morley | |
| 1869 – 1872 Rev. Andrew Sharp | |
| 1872 – 1882 Rev. Aurelian H. Post | |
| 1882 – 1884 Rev. Charles M. McNulty | |
| 1884 – 1889 Rev. William Haynes | |
| 1889 – 1895 Rev. Charles H. Lemmon | |
| 1895 – 1898 Rev. A. Wilmer Swengel | |
| 1899 – 1902 Rev. Joseph Wolfe | |
| 1902 – 1905 Rev. Arthur T. Reed | |
| 1905 – 1911 Rev. Walter R. Blackmer | |
| 1911 – 1912 Rev. Fraser | |
| 1912 – 1916 Rev. Roselle Theodore Cross | |
| 1917 – 1919 Rev. John L. Conant | |
| 1919 – 1920 Rev. R.T. Cross supplied. | |
| 1920 – 1925 Rev. Wm. C.H. Moe | |
| 1925 – 1929 Rev. J.M. Allison | |
| 1930 – 1935 Rev. W.A. Mulder | |
| 1936 – 1937 Rev. Thorley Johnson | |
| 1938 – 1939 Various supplies, one of whom was Rev. H.L. Torbett. | |
| 1939 – 1943 Rev. William H. Longsworth | |
| 1944 – 1953 Rev. L. Austin Lippitt | |
| 1954 – 1959 Rev. W.R. Stevenson | |
| 1960 – 1969 Rev. John Bruce | |
| 1970 – 1971 Rev. Fred Olson | |
| 1972 – 1991 Rev. Dewey J. Long | |
| 1993 – 1998 Rev. Greg Russell | |
| 1998 – 6/30/02 Rev. Patricia Jefferis | |
| 09/29/03 – 08/06/08 Rev. Dr. Greg Coles | |
| 08/03/08 – 12/31/2015 Rev. Kay Krejci | |
| 1/18/2016 – 1/31/2016 Andrew Courtney | |
| 2/1/2016 – 4/15/2018 Rev. Andrew Courtney and Rev. Sarah Courtney | |
| 4/16/2018 – 10/31/2018 Various Supply Ministers and Guest Speakers | |
| 11/1/2018 – 10/31/2019 Interim Designate Minister David Zerby | |
| 11/1/2019 – 10/1/2020 Pastor Jeff Jackson | |
| 7/1/2022 – 6/28/2026 Pastor Greg Hogan | |
| 8/10/2026 – Present Pastor Karsten Snitker | |
| |
